Comedy legend Martin Short has officially set the bar for the ultimate celebrity wedding fail, revealing this week that he accidentally sliced into Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco’s wedding cake before the bride and groom even had a chance to see it. The Only Murders in the Building star shared the hilarious confession during an appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live!, sparking a viral frenzy across social media as fans fell in love with his chaotic wedding guest energy. According to Short, the mishap occurred during the couple's star-studded reception, where a misunderstanding about the dessert layout led to a moment of pure panic.

The Hilarious "Self-Serve" Mistake

During his interview with Kimmel on Wednesday, Short detailed the sequence of events that led to the now-famous Martin Short funny stories entry. The wedding, which took place in September 2025 at a stunning venue in Santa Barbara, featured a massive reception tent with individual lounge areas for guests. Short was seated with his OMITB co-stars, including Steve Martin and Paul Rudd, when he spotted what he believed to be a complimentary dessert station.

"There was a wedding cake by our section, but it was a small wedding cake," Short explained to the laughing audience. "I just assumed there was a wedding cake for each section in the back!" The situation escalated when Steve Martin mentioned he needed to leave the party early. Determined not to let his friend depart without a sweet treat, Short took matters into his own hands—literally.

"I had a fork in my hand. I said, 'Steve, you can't leave yet without a piece of wedding cake!'" Short recalled. "And I cut the wedding cake—one side, then the other. And then all the people in our group screamed, 'Marty!'" It turns out, the "small" cake was actually a specific tier meant for the ceremonial cutting, placed temporarily near their VIP section.

Performing "Surgery" on the Cake

The aftermath of the blunder was just as chaotic as the act itself. Realizing he had just vandalized the centerpiece of Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco’s nuptials, Short and his tablemates went into damage control mode. "I tried to fix it with a fork," he admitted, describing the result as "bad." The actor joked that the catering staff had to perform emergency "surgery" on the confection.

"It ended up being like a Hollywood wedding cake—it was beautiful, but it had a little work done," Short quipped, delivering one of the night's best lines. Fortunately, the wedding coordinator and chef were able to smooth over the frosting just in time for the official presentation. Short noted that he spent the rest of the evening terrified that Gomez would notice the patch job, joking to Steve Martin, "Maybe we tell her in a month or so."

Inside Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco’s Wedding

While Short’s cake mishap is currently dominating viral celebrity news 2026, the wedding itself was a fairytale affair. Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco tied the knot on September 27, 2025, in an intimate ceremony surrounded by A-list friends, including Taylor Swift, Ed Sheeran, and the cast of Only Murders in the Building. Selena Gomez wedding photos 2026 have shown the bride in a custom Ralph Lauren gown, celebrating what she called her "perfect day."

The couple, who went public with their relationship in late 2023, have quickly become one of Hollywood's favorite pairings. Short’s anecdote highlights the close-knit, familial bond he shares with Gomez, whom he often refers to as a "third grandchild." Despite the cake debacle, Short emphasized that the rest of the evening was flawless, praising the couple's love and the "dreamy" atmosphere of the night.

Fans React to the "Chaotic Uncle" Energy

As expected, the internet has wasted no time turning Short’s confession into a meme format. Social media platforms are flooded with clips from the interview, with users hailing Short as the relatable "agent of chaos" every wedding needs. The story has joined the ranks of legendary celebrity wedding fails, serving as a reminder that even the most glamorous events aren't immune to a little human error.

"Martin Short treating a wedding cake like a sample at Costco is the energy I'm bringing to 2026," one user tweeted. Another added, "Only Marty could almost ruin Selena’s wedding and make it the highlight of the event." It seems that rather than ruining the day, Short’s fork-wielding faux pas has only added to the charm of the Martin Short Benny Blanco family dynamic.